Hello dear
Welcome To Lovejoy Pizzeria
**About Lovejoy Pizzeria** Nestled at 1244 E Lovejoy St in Buffalo, Lovejoy Pizzeria offers a nostalgic dive into authentic pizza culture. Known for their consistently exceptional "Buffalo pies," they craft each pizza with care, bringing back the authentic flavors of traditional pizzerias. Their menu also boasts a variety of hot and cold subs, with standout options like the Turkey Club and tantalizing cheese fries. Customers rave about the friendly service, speedy delivery, and the delightful atmosphere, enhanced by catchy 80s tunes. Each visit promises a satisfying experience that keeps patrons returning for more. Lovejoy Pizzeria is truly a hidden gem in Buffalo.
About
Lovejoy Pizzeria
Welcome to Lovejoy Pizzeria, a hidden gem nestled at 1244 E Lovejoy St, Buffalo, NY. Known for its authentic Buffalo pie, this pizzeria has become a beloved destination for locals. With a prime location and a commitment to quality, it's no surprise that Lovejoy Pizzeria has built a loyal following over the years.
Step inside and you'll immediately experience the inviting ambiance, complete with catchy 80's tunes playing in the background, transporting you back in time. The friendly staff, like the charming gentleman behind the counter, makes every visit memorable, ensuring that your pizza or sub is not just food, but an experience. As one satisfied customer, Morgan Adams, raved, “A real Buffalo pie. I’ve never been disappointed with anything else we’ve tried on the menu.”
The menu offers a delightful range of choices. If you’re in the mood for pizza, the flavors are bold and authentic. Customers like TJB have declared the BBQ chicken pizza “phenomenal,” and it’s clear that Lovejoy Pizzeria pays homage to traditional recipes while incorporating delicious twists. Those looking for something more portable can dive into their selection of cold and hot subs, each crafted to perfection. The turkey and capicola sub, praised by Genine TenBroeck, comes with a special oil that is sure to impress even the most discerning palate.
And let’s talk about customization! With extra ingredients like fried onions, mushrooms, and Big John's sliced stuffed hot peppers, Lovejoy Pizzeria keeps the flavors fresh and exciting. This flexibility empowers you to create your perfect meal every time.
With the rising trend of non-franchised eateries, Lovejoy stands apart from the crowded landscape. As Stephen Ashcroft put it, there is a nostalgic taste to their offerings that he hasn't experienced in years. This genuine approach to pizza-making speaks volumes about their dedication to the craft. So whether you’re a lifelong Buffalonian or just passing through, Lovejoy Pizzeria is a must-visit for anyone yearning for a true taste of Buffalo.
In short, Lovejoy Pizzeria isn’t just a place to grab a slice; it’s a celebration of community, tradition, and flavor. So, why wait? Pick up the phone and call +1 716-891-9233 to place your order, and experience for yourself why this pizzeria has earned its stellar reputation!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Been ordering from here for friday night pizza regularly for the last 3 years and never found a place in buffalo thats consistently amazing every time. A real buffalo pie. Ive also never been disappointed from anything else weve tried on the menu. 10/10 highly recommend ”
“ The guy behind the counter was friendly and really cute! I asked for my Pizza at 7:15 and it was ready right on the dot! Tasty pizza too! Would visit again! 67 for 3 large pizzas with toppings on each of them! Catchy music from the 80’s being played too while you wait! ”
“ Had a turkey and capicola sub. Oil on the side. I don't know what you put in your oil but it blows the doors off of Jim's steakout's. I loved my sub and it was perfect. I never say that ”
“ We ordered a bbq chicken pizza & it was phenomenal. That’s the first time I’ve ever had pizza from there and I’ll definitely order this pizza again for sure. I should’ve took the photo when we first got the pizza. ”
“ It’s very hard to find a non franchised pizzeria. Growing up I worked for one and now it seams so different. My friend recommended this place and I was like eh idk I had not actually been impressed with a good pie since the 2000’s... until now.! I tip my hat to you guys! It’s been a long while since I actually enjoyed a non generic pizza!!! I’d give this place well more than five stars if I could for taste and authenticity to what pizza used to and should still be! Thanks guys for bringing the past back! ”
“ I don't like pizza and I don't believe in god, but this mannah was kissed by Jesus and sent from the heavens on the wings of angels to give us mere mortals a glimpse of what the afterlife is like. This is the cheese pull we have all been coveting since The Goofy Movie in 1995. ”
“ A friend recommended their subs and it was a bumpy ride(all my fault), but so worth it. I unknowingly placed an order at the Main St. location. When a pickup was attempted on Clinton, I realized my mistake. Replaced the order at the Clinton St. restaurant and called to make good on my original order. The owner wouldn’t let me pay for the mistake I made. The Yum-Yum sub was out of this world. I can’t wait to try the others on the menu. This place is a true gem to the area. ”
“ I’ve been meaning to try this place for a long time, finally did on Saturday just before the Bills game. 45-hour wait, to be expected and definitely NOT disappointed. My wife isn’t a big pizza eater and when she said today, two days after just placing our first order that she wanted it again I was pleasantly excited. Our pizza was perfect and the wings were super crispy and very tasty. We can’t wait to try other items on the menu, they all sound fantastic. Now the tough part is trying to decide which to choose next knowing that the pizza is in the back of my mind always. ”